The Florida Keys Best Places to Stay

Below is a listing of the ten best places to stay in the Florida Keys as voted by our visitors.

Check out all of their favorites and then let us know what you think. Agree, disagree, or comment on any of their choices by filling out the contact form!

1
Key Lime Sailing Club
Key Largo

Secluded, low-key cottages with lots of bonus amenities! 22 foot sailboat available with every cabin rental! Accommodations for couples as well as families with up to 6 children. Snorkel & fishing gear also available for no charge!

Your rating: 5 Average: 3.7 (591 votes)
2
Harbor Lights Motel
Islamorada

Islamorada Motel with pool, boat ramp and boat docks

Your rating: 5 Average: 3.3 (105 votes)
3
La Siesta Resort and Marina
Islamorada

La Siesta is located just off the highway in a tropical setting of mature palms in Islamorada.  Cottages have full kitchens where you can cook your catch!  Complimentary use of bicycles and fishing rods.  Newly remodeled.

Your rating: 5 Average: 5 (1 vote)
4
Cheeca Lodge and Spa
Islamorada

Beautiful and secluded, Cheeca Lodge & Spa in Islamorada offers outstanding hospitality and accommodations.  Enjoy fishing off the 525 foot pier, relax in a beach hammock or indulge yourself in in the Spa.  Several Florida Keys vacation packages to choose from.

Your rating: 5 Average: 3.7 (175 votes)
5
Coral Bay Resort
Islamorada

Cottages styled after historic keys homes on Lower Matecumbe.  Coral Bay Resort in Islamorada offers a relaxing getaway for couples and families.  Enjoy the sun in the freshwater pool or sandy beach.  Boat ramp and dock are available at no extra charge. 

Your rating: 5 Average: 3.1 (19 votes)
6
Hawks Cay Island Resort
Marathon

Island Resort located on the 60 acre island of Duck Key. Resort with full amenities. Five pools, fishing, diving, water sports, restaurants, full-service marina, spa, dolphin encounters, guest rooms, suites, and villas. Weddings and special event rentals also available. Spoil yourself at this luxury resort!

Your rating: 5 Average: 3.8 (137 votes)
7
Indigo Reef Resort Villas & Marina
Marathon

2 and 3 bedroom waterview villas with "Conch" style architecture, many with private dock and porch. Easy access to Gulf and Atlantic. Enjoy local fishing and many amenities such as WIFI, spa, 42" TVs, spacious floor plans.

Your rating: 5 Average: 3.1 (7 votes)
8
Seascape Motel and Marina
Marathon

"Off the beaten path" motel on 4.5 tropical acres with 500 feet of private beach. Dock space & boat ramp available. Fishing service available at marina. Comfortable, affordable variety of rooms.
 

Your rating: 5 Average: 3.6 (71 votes)
9
CocoPlum Beach & Tennis Club
Marathon

2/2 vacation homes on a lush, tropically landscaped property. Fully equipped kitchens and washer/dryer. Docks, tiki huts, heated pool add to the charm of this luxurious resort.
 

Your rating: 5 Average: 3.5 (13 votes)
10
Hawks Nest
Marathon

Spacious 1-2 room units in the heart of the Florida Keys. Pool, hot tub, tennis, fishing docks, onsite boat rentals, BBQs, bicycles, tiki huts, and a game room. In the middle of the water-sport capital of Florida! Only an hour from Key West!
 

Your rating: 5 Average: 3.9 (43 votes)

Restaurant Ideas

Half Shell Raw Bar
Key West
Rob's Island Grill
Big Pine Key and the Lower Keys
Sloppy Joe's Bar
Key West

Hotel Ideas

Conch Key Cottages
Marathon
The Barnacle Bed and Breakfast
Big Pine Key and the Lower Keys
Seaward Resort Motel
Marathon

Login