a Florida Keys vacation planning resource

Best Places to Stay
in the Florida Keys
Visitors'
Top 10 Picks

The Keys
Best Restaurants

Top 10 Picks

Best Restaurants in the Florida Keys

Below is a listing of the ten best restaurants as voted by our visitors.

Take a peek at some of our favorites and then tell us exactly what you think. Agree, disagree, or comment on their choices by filling out the contact form!

1
Key Largo

Waterfront bar and restaurant with live music, drink specials. Featuring fresh local seafood with an eclectic menu of Caribbean, Mexican and Asian dishes.

4.0625
Average: 4.1 (16 votes)
2
Marathon

Waterfront eatery with reasonable prices and great food.

3.642855
Average: 3.6 (14 votes)
3
Islamorada

Holiday Isle Resort and Marina, located in Islamorada, Florida, where you can experience all the Keys has to offer: dining, diving, flats or offshore fishing and don't forget their world famous Tiki Bar, Jaws Raw Bar, and Rumrunners Island Bar!  Pet friendly.

2.75
Average: 2.8 (16 votes)
4
Big Pine Key

Contemporary, trendy, upscale seafood restaurant with great ambiance and delectable selections. Well worth stopping on way down or home from Key West! Best Grouper sandwich in the keys.

3.5
Average: 3.5 (10 votes)
5
Big Pine Key

Oldest bar in Big Pine Key, walls are literally covered in thousands of dollar bills. Casual dining, featuring awesome pizza, chili, smoked fish dip and sandwiches. One of a kind Key's experience.

3.875
Average: 3.9 (8 votes)
6
Islamorada

Robbie's of Islamorada is a one-stop dining, shopping, diving, and relaxing destination in Islamorada, FL. Fishing and dive charters leave daily from the marina and can be booked online or by phone. Robbie's of Islamorada also features guided tours, boat rentals, and tarpon feeding. And when you're done feeding the tarpon, feed yourself at the Hungry Tarpon Restaurant.

3.076925
Average: 3.1 (13 votes)
7
Key Largo

Rustic, floating, open-air seafood restaurant. Enjoy beers with some of the local bikers! And killer fresh blue crab cakes. Lots of traditional key's food. Come early, they close at 7 when the skeeters come out!

3.625
Average: 3.6 (8 votes)
8
Key West

Internationally known since 1933! Historic Sloppy Joe's bar, the legendary Hemingway's hangout, is full of history along with plenty of delicious drinks and savory eats! Open from 9am to 4am everyday. Live music starts at noon and continues throughout the day. Cool AC as well!
 

3.5
Average: 3.5 (2 votes)
9
Big Pine Key

Local breakfast diner, great food, large portions, and very affordable! Laid-back, cozy atmosphere. (Try the crabcake eggs benedict!)
 

4.5
Average: 4.5 (2 votes)
10
Islamorada

World famous seafood buffet since 1976! Over 80 items including, crablegs, shrimp, oysters, mussels, crab cakes, paella, conch fritters, stir fry, sushi. Also plenty of non-seafood options like pizza, ribs, wings and steaks. And salads & desserts to boot!

3
Average: 3 (2 votes)